ES Xeon Discussion

Notice: Page may contain affiliate links for which we may earn a small commission through services like Amazon Affiliates or Skimlinks.

DHamov

Active Member
Jan 12, 2024
120
29
28
If one would run 2 QYFS (2x350W) on a GIBABYTE MS73-HB1 dual socket board (2x270W) are they restricted in performance, in the sense that for example Boost/Turbo's are not working?

Can they pull more than 270W each on the board?

A single QYFS does CB R23 score 65K, but i could not find any values of screenshots with 2xQYFS benchmarks, it would be interesting to know that score.
 
Last edited:

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,247
2,963
113
germany
If one would run 2 QYFS (2x350W) on a GIBABYTE MS73-HB1 dual socket board (2x270W) are they restricted in performance, in the sense that for example Boost/Turbo's are not working?
i can say only this: they work on MS73-HB2 - cinebenchR24 all cores 2800mhz and draw each around 350W.
we have not enough memory to give valid results.
A single QYFS does CB R23 score 65K, but i could not find any values of screenshots with 2xQYFS benchmarks, it would be interesting to know that score.
i see scores only 88000 pts with 2x 8490H QS CBR23 but can be with only two RAM modules or whatever.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHamov

heromode

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2020
534
327
63
just tried to snipe a MS73-HB1 just for fun, i offered 510 EUR about 7 seconds before the end.. wonder what would have happened if i had offered 520.. lol, nothing would have happened i'm sure.. It's a brutal game this.

GIBABYTE MS73-HB1 Dual LGA4677 4th Intel Xeon E-ATX motherboard DDR5 4800 MHz | eBay

Oh well, on to the next one..

Edit, on another thought, maybe off of stupid intel and their overpriced shit. Maybe time to embrace the chinese markets, and stop worrying
 

DHamov

Active Member
Jan 12, 2024
120
29
28
just tried to snipe a MS73-HB1 just for fun, i offered 510 EUR about 7 seconds before the end.. wonder what would have happened if i had offered 520.. lol, nothing would have happened i'm sure.. It's a brutal game this.

GIBABYTE MS73-HB1 Dual LGA4677 4th Intel Xeon E-ATX motherboard DDR5 4800 MHz | eBay

Oh well, on to the next one..
Haha i was also bidding on that one, my last bid of 580 did not get trough in time. Was really kind of frustrated about that. These Mainboards do not pop up very often, especially for these prices. My only imaginary comfort is to think that it was maybe faulty, who would sell such a thing now, for such a price? I feld almost bad for the seller. He seemed a nice, guy even sent me a screenshot of when he bought it. In Europe these boards are hard to get, by reputable channels at the moment, even if you are ready to pay double of this. He also bought it from ebay, and seller in China, there is almost no other choice, but probably not very good warranty, i don't know maybe Gigabyte is not so picky with sales channels.
 
Last edited:

sam55todd

Active Member
May 11, 2023
212
65
28
If one would run 2 QYFS (2x350W) on a GIBABYTE MS73-HB1 dual socket board (2x270W) are they restricted in performance, in the sense that for example Boost/Turbo's are not working?

Can they pull more than 270W each on the board?
Electronics operating in environments outside/above characteristics these were designed for - tends to rapidly degrade and drifting away from initial specifications. e.g. VRMs/MOSFETs handling higher currents will likely to get permanently distorted parameters (gates/junctions don't function as designed) or get overheat damage (same with capacitors operating above specified temperatures) - not necessarily in one day (for instance with warranty of 2 years it gradually gets permanently glitchy in just 3 months, with first unexpected PC crash in 1 month, then in 2 weeks, then more frequently), generally systems becomes unstable leading to crashes/freezes/lockdowns, this kind of mainboard damage mostly is not covered by warranty.
I'm pretty sure most manufacturers do put detection protection in BIOS to prevent booting CPUs out of designed range (and might have some memory storage buffers to store information if these rules were overridden by user).
This is one of the reasons why using ES on MB where manufacturer has specified approved/certified CPUs might void warranty.
 
Last edited:

heromode

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2020
534
327
63
Haha i was also bidding on that one, my last bid of 580 did not get trough in time. Was really kind of frustrated about that. These Mainboards do not pop up very often, especially for these prices. My only imaginary comfort is to think that it was maybe faulty, who would sell such a thing now, for such a price? I feld almost bad for the seller. He seemed a nice, guy even sent me a screenshot of when he bought it. In Europe these boards are hard to get, by reputable channels at the moment, even if you are ready to pay double of this. He also bought it from ebay, and seller in China, there is almost no other choice, but probably not very good warranty, i don't know maybe Gigabyte is not so picky with sales channels.
lol, he's italian, who knows.. might be a scam, or a perfectly valid trade. I bought my xeon E-2186G from a private italian seller for 220 EUR now 2 years ago, it's still a good price today. maximum risk, maximum gain.

But anything from Italy is high risk as well.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHamov

heromode

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2020
534
327
63
basically the current price levels of these scalable gen4/5 mobo's is determined by CPU mined crypto's, and xeon ES price points, made extremely clear by @RolloZ170.

Now, all this is linked to the global financial system, and thus the current global reserve currency, and thus, US domestic politics, and the question about the candidate Donald J. Trump.

That is the reason all MS73-HBx motherboards are trading at about $1500 ATM. If i was a betting man (which i am), and i had the money, i'd pay that price today.
 

scouzi

Member
Jan 8, 2024
39
7
8
basically the current price levels of these scalable gen4/5 mobo's is determined by CPU mined crypto's, and xeon ES price points, made extremely clear by @RolloZ170.

Now, all this is linked to the global financial system, and thus the current global reserve currency, and thus, US domestic politics, and the question about the candidate Donald J. Trump.

That is the reason all MS73-HBx motherboards are trading at about $1500 ATM. If i was a betting man (which i am), and i had the money, i'd pay that price today.
What? The crypto market is driving some demand for Sapphire Rapids? Which coins?

Also have a question. Can I run MS73-HBx with only one CPU? What is the penalty? Might want to go dual in the near future but I don't want to commit right away.
 

heromode

Well-Known Member
May 25, 2020
534
327
63
What? The crypto market is driving some demand for Sapphire Rapids? Which coins?
here you can calculate the monthly and annual value of your mobo + cpu.

CryptUnit - Hi. What are you mining today?

then you can compare the results to the prices of all motherboards and cpu's especially on the chinese markets. You will arrive at a 1:1 result, when you include the price of electricity in your area.
 

DHamov

Active Member
Jan 12, 2024
120
29
28
What? The crypto market is driving some demand for Sapphire Rapids? Which coins?

Also have a question. Can I run MS73-HBx with only one CPU? What is the penalty? Might want to go dual in the near future but I don't want to commit right away.
Yesterday i spoke with an ebay seller he run a single QYFS on MS73-HB1 with two memory sticks 4800 and got 63K CBR23, which is pretty amazing because a QYFS in ASUS W790 is doing about 65K, with fancy power and thermal settings, all dimm slots populated and 5600Mhz mem. Also the MS73 has 2 M.2 gen 4 directly to the cpu. But then again if the board is only for 270W, and you run a 350W cpu, there might be some long term durability issues as discussed above. But maybe if you only run one 350W cpu instead of two 270W maybe there is no problem. Strangly enough the MS73 seems to have more power connectors than the Supermicro X13DAI-T which is ok for 2x350W.
 
Last edited:

DHamov

Active Member
Jan 12, 2024
120
29
28
pls ask before, there are some exceptions in this rule.
i.e. QY36 = stepping C2, like QXxx
if you get a HPE server with very early BIOS you are lucky, but have to stay with old BIOS until the last days.
Is there anything known about the QYK8, in regard to compatibility with Asus w790?
The sellers list only ms33-ar0, but on the screenshot, i can see they probably run it on a MS73.
The seller answers: 'we tested the product, it is only compatible with Server board and w790 is a workstation board.'
But i am not really convinced if he really knows. On the other hand, the ms33-ar0 is single socket but has Intel® C741 Chipset, and not the w790 chipset, can that be relevant for compatibility, or is compatibility only a bios issue?
 

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,247
2,963
113
germany
But maybe if you only run one 350W cpu instead of two 270W maybe there is no problem. Strangly enough the MS73 seems to have more power connectors than the Supermicro X13DAI-T which is ok for 2x350W.
it is sometimes just price politics.
the X11SPL-F ( max.165W ) i.e. use the SAME VRM unit than X11SPi-TF ( max. 205W )
the MS73-HBx ( max. 2x 270W ) use the SAME VRM config. than MS33-AR0 ( max. 350W )
but if you run MS73 in a server chassis, the second CPU gets hot Air of the first and gets 15-20C hotter.
 

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,247
2,963
113
germany
Is there anything known about the QYK8, in regard to compatibility with Asus w790?
The sellers list only ms33-ar0, but on the screenshot, i can see they probably run it on a MS73.
The seller answers: 'we tested the product, it is only compatible with Server board and w790 is a workstation board.'
i bet if you ask if QYFS works on ASUS W790, he answers the same, most seller do still not know.
On the other hand, the ms33-ar0 is single socket but has Intel® C741 Chipset, and not the w790 chipset, can that be relevant for compatibility, or is compatibility only a bios issue?
SPR-SP D0 ES2 can do DMI4 (PCH<->CPU interface) maybe this is initial required,
and platform configuration bits are important.
 

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,247
2,963
113
germany
Is there anything known about the QYK8, in regard to compatibility with Asus w790?
well i have not tested this model but ALL D0 ES2 i have tested are working on ASUS W790 ( QYFQ,QYFP,QY06,QY0C,QYFS... )
btw:
ASRock W790 WS board keeps D0 microcode as well, maybe someone has the chance to check if D0 ES2 runs on it too, would not wondering me.
 

scouzi

Member
Jan 8, 2024
39
7
8
I'm looking to start with 256 GB RAM with my build. With an 8 slot board, probably 4x64GB to start and keep some spare for expansion. I could also go 8x32GB and get the full 8 channels with no flexibility left for expansion. Is there a significant real-life noticeable difference between 4 channels and 8 channels?
 
  • Like
Reactions: DHamov

bayleyw

Active Member
Jan 8, 2014
333
109
43
basically the current price levels of these scalable gen4/5 mobo's is determined by CPU mined crypto's, and xeon ES price points, made extremely clear by @RolloZ170.

Now, all this is linked to the global financial system, and thus the current global reserve currency, and thus, US domestic politics, and the question about the candidate Donald J. Trump.

That is the reason all MS73-HBx motherboards are trading at about $1500 ATM. If i was a betting man (which i am), and i had the money, i'd pay that price today.
what in tarnation is this fake news, you can get any Gigabyte motherboard you want for MSRP right now https://www.newegg.com/p/pl?N=50001314 100161257 8000&Manufactory=1314 and it is beyond the realm of possibility that Mr. Trump has any connection to the price of bootleg server processors on eBay

I'm looking to start with 256 GB RAM with my build. With an 8 slot board, probably 4x64GB to start and keep some spare for expansion. I could also go 8x32GB and get the full 8 channels with no flexibility left for expansion. Is there a significant real-life noticeable difference between 4 channels and 8 channels?
Depends on the workload, on one end HPCG and its use cases are entirely bandwidth bound, some AI workloads are as well, on the other end dense matrices and ray tracing are not bandwidth limited at all