ES Xeon Discussion

Notice: Page may contain affiliate links for which we may earn a small commission through services like Amazon Affiliates or Skimlinks.

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,953
3,193
113
germany
Would Intel Xeon Platinum 8280 ES QQ87 with steppings of B1 be a good CPU or should I pass on it? Mainly wondering if the stepping is good.
QQ87 is A0 50655, microcode not supported by intel since 2019
Intel / HP latest BIOS lacks this microcode.
 
Apr 4, 2021
6
0
1
I'm currently running two 8268 ES qq9e on a X11DPI-NT with bios 3.6 and get memory controller errors when I try to populate 4 Intel 256gb dcpmms. I have am using TSV ram. Anyone have insight into if what might be the issue before i send back the optane?
 

fhpchris

New Member
Aug 13, 2023
1
0
1
i got some more POST codes with injected C-stepping microccode in the BIOS. the ref.codes may too actual to init.the old stepping thought.

normaly not the task of ME. and same cpuid and microcode.
i noticed the D-Stepping run with DMI4x8 on my W790 Ace. maybe E steppings SPR-SP can't.
btw: D0 cpuid806f3 is PRD stepping
View attachment 31569
Does this mean that D0 ES SPR is like the stepping 6 Ice Lake xeons and we are likely to see long term support on the W790 Ace? I was thinking of building an Ice Lake system with the stepping 6 ES or QS but it looks like using a D0 ES2 SPR-SP is better? What do you think?
 

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,953
3,193
113
germany
Does this mean that D0 ES SPR is like the stepping 6 Ice Lake xeons and we are likely to see long term support on the W790 Ace?
no. Ice Lake D0 is production stepping microcode and latest.
606A4 - Ice Lake-SP B0/L0 (LGA4189)
606A5 - Ice Lake-SP C0 (LGA4189)
606A6 - Ice Lake-SP M0/M1 D0/D1/D2 (LGA4189)

Sapphire Rapids D0 microcode is marked as production but has successors E0,E2,E3,E4,and E5.
806F0/97, "A"
806F1/10, "HBM A" Xeon Max
806F1/87, "B"
806F2/87, "C"
806F3/87, "D0/R0" (D0 is XCC, R0 if MCC)
806F4/87, "E0/S1"
806F5/87, "E2/B1"
806F5/10, "HBM?"
806F6/87, "E3/S2"
806F7/87, "E4/S2"
806F8/87, "E5/S3/B3" (actual latest)
806F8/10, "HBM B" Xeon Max (actual latest)

Physical Chope xample:
806F8/87, "E5/S3/B3"
E5 = XCC ( 4 tiles)
S3 = MCC (single die)
B3 = XCC ( 4 tiles) + HBM
 
Last edited:

sam55todd

Active Member
May 11, 2023
215
66
28
Referencing post above - just saw SPR with strange E5/S3 stepping during one of today's communications with sellers over the ebay..
(for some reasons most of them are a bit lazy to publish details about ES/QS or correct CPU pictures with product code and production date lines to derive QS generation, and consequently expected stability and functionality)..
1695197848986.png

Although prices are still beyond reach for QS..
 

sam55todd

Active Member
May 11, 2023
215
66
28
I've asked every China-based ebay supplier (about dozen already) for a picture of actual SPR QS CPU label (to derive production date from FPO and QS generation) - everyone either keeps pretending they don't understand or dodging with sending some other information).. IMV that is a bit of a red flag, I wouldn't want to get any QS produced in first half of 2022, prefer getting Q4-22 or Q1-23 (if those exist),, worst case Q3-22 but sellers really do make this very difficult.

Perhaps it's worth just keeping an existing 8461V kindly sold by kizune, and wait for proper discontinuation of SPR by DCs while they move to Emerald Rapids.
 

Stephan

Well-Known Member
Apr 21, 2017
1,117
878
113
Germany
They know what is up very well, hence the "nix verstehen" tactic. Big red flag. Money is tight even at hyperscalers for the next 2-3 years I imagine, replacement could take awhile. Unless security landscape forces their hand should a -50% integer performance critical fix become necessary. Make sure to qualify all DIMM sockets and also PCIe slots that they work after CPU swap. 50% yields of Intel 7 tells me the other 50% also have higher fail rates when subjected to a few months of intensive workloads. I like the more solid stuff hence 14nm++ i.e. no later than Cascade Lake.
 
  • Like
Reactions: sam55todd

Spelon1

New Member
Feb 5, 2021
8
1
3
Anyone know of any cascade lake QS with large memory support working on HP DL360/380? I'd love to test out optane since they are getting cheap on ebay.
 

Spelon1

New Member
Feb 5, 2021
8
1
3
Seller offered it ($200) so figured I could test it out, worst case I'll swap it to one of the gigabyte servers. I assume there will be some trial and error to get any HP working. Thanks for helping me tho.
 
  • Like
Reactions: RolloZ170
Jul 19, 2020
51
20
8
Does anyone have any experience with the Tyan S5652 and the Sapphire Rapids ES/QS parts? Would a D0 stepping part work in that board?
 
Jul 19, 2020
51
20
8
Thanks, good to know. It's a big thread, I did see that supermicro is no good for ES parts, but I guess I missed the comments on Tyan.

What about the ASRock Rack SPC741D8-2L2T or GIGABYTE MS03-CE0? I'm trying to find something relatively economical that has lots of usable PCIe x16 slots, and I don't really need more than one CPU. MS33-AR0 is not very interesting because half the slots are blocked by the RAM. MS73-HB1 I guess might be a decent option, but I don't really need two CPUs and with only one CPU installed presumably some of the PCIe slots will not be usable. I suppose ASRock Rack SPC741D16X-2T might also be an option worth considering, similar setup as the MS73-HB1.
 

RolloZ170

Well-Known Member
Apr 24, 2016
9,953
3,193
113
germany
What about the ASRock Rack SPC741D8-2L2T or GIGABYTE MS03-CE0?
ASRock C741 series supports ONLY E-Stepping ES/QS/PRD processors, same than supermicro/Tyan.
(the BIOS of ASRockRack/Gigabyte/Tyan can be modded,)
Currently ALL Gigabyte C741 boards support D0 stepping SPR-SP ES. if you update BIOS, don't update Intel SPS/ME.
edit: Intel SPS/ME allows SPR D0 up to latest BIOS
QYFP MS03.jpg
 
Last edited: