I don't wanna sound like a broken record, so please take this as constructive criticism.
I'm still not getting why you need to add complexity to your network. You have a very simple, flat network. There doesn't seem to be any logical reason to add complexity.
- You want to separate guests and give them internet access only? A consumer router does that with a separate guest wifi
- I'm not seeing the need for VLANs anywhere.
- routing at the switch level...this is a can of worms. Unless you really need VLANs (which it seem you don't) a dumb L2 switch will still route at the switch level based on the Mac address.
- Where did 10g come from? You don't seem to have 10g equipment right now.
- If you need POE, sure go ahead and get a POE switch, but there's still no logical reason to go down the L3/managed switch rabbit hole.
That all being said, don't get me wrong, if you just wanna do it, do it. But do it for the right reasons.
I'm still not getting why you need to add complexity to your network. You have a very simple, flat network. There doesn't seem to be any logical reason to add complexity.
- You want to separate guests and give them internet access only? A consumer router does that with a separate guest wifi
- I'm not seeing the need for VLANs anywhere.
- routing at the switch level...this is a can of worms. Unless you really need VLANs (which it seem you don't) a dumb L2 switch will still route at the switch level based on the Mac address.
- Where did 10g come from? You don't seem to have 10g equipment right now.
- If you need POE, sure go ahead and get a POE switch, but there's still no logical reason to go down the L3/managed switch rabbit hole.
That all being said, don't get me wrong, if you just wanna do it, do it. But do it for the right reasons.