SuperMicro 4U CSE-847 36 Bay SAS2 BP X9DRD-EF 2x E5-2620 12 Core 16GB IT Mode

Jiaxinxi

Member
Aug 23, 2017
77
43
18
52
I bought another item from them.
I think it is decently priced.
SuperMicro 4U CSE-846 24 Bay SAS2 BP X9DRi-F/2x W/ 2x E5-2620 16GB IT MODE for $369

Since purchase I already bought few other items to update the machine
  1. 2 x E5-2670
  2. 4 x 32GB (128GB) PC3-14900L Memory
  3. Intel X520-DA2 10GB card
  4. 10 x 3TB SAS Hard drive
Needs to stop spending on this!

But I really want to fill all the blanks. There are still 12 memory bank empty. I really want to feel them up.

Can I mix the memory?
Mix PC3-14900L with PC3-8500R?
If so I can buy few cheap 8500R stick to fill all the memory bank.
 
  • Like
Reactions: lxr3517 and Samir

Samir

Post Liker and Deal Hunter Extraordinaire!
Jul 21, 2017
2,522
1,032
113
47
HSV and SFO
You probably can fill them up with pc3-8500r, but you're not going to get the best performance from it doing that and your other memory will clock down and increase power usage.

If you just want all the slots filled, trade with me as I have a bunch of 2gb and 4gb modules that will use up all the slots. :D Definitely better than just 4x 32gb modules and all those empty slots, dontcha think? ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: itronin

itronin

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2018
963
616
93
Denver, Colorado
@Jiaxinxi - load reduced (L) can't be mixed with normal registered.
Also as you fill up more slots with those 32GB the memory performance will clock down anyway. then again with just 4 you probably won't. I think 8 dimms is probably the optimum number, 4 per CPU.

@Samir is correct though you can possibly use other registered dimms of a higher clock and they will all clock down to the lowest speed dimm.

@Samir - that's just ..just... just.. cheeky! :p haha!
 

Jiaxinxi

Member
Aug 23, 2017
77
43
18
52
@Jiaxinxi - load reduced (L) can't be mixed with normal registered.
Also as you fill up more slots with those 32GB the memory performance will clock down anyway. then again with just 4 you probably won't. I think 8 dimms is probably the optimum number, 4 per CPU.

@Samir is correct though you can possibly use other registered dimms of a higher clock and they will all clock down to the lowest speed dimm.

@Samir - that's just ..just... just.. cheeky! :p haha!
@Samir I was looking for those cheap 2 gb DIMMS just to to fill the memory banks. But I think it will not work well with the 32Gb modules.

@itronin Thanks for your info. Now I know what L means after the speed. I thought it means lower power consumption.

I just feel guilty to have only 4DIMMs installed. They looks so lonely on this giant motherboard.:D;);)
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sleyk

itronin

Well-Known Member
Nov 24, 2018
963
616
93
Denver, Colorado
@Samir I was looking for those cheap 2 gb DIMMS just to to fill the memory banks. But I think it will not work well with the 32Gb modules.

@itronin Thanks for your info. Now I know what L means after the speed. I thought it means lower power consumption.

I just feel guilty to have only 4DIMMs installed. They looks so lonely on this giant motherboard.:D;);)
L stands for Load reduced, I'm not enough of an EE to explain how that works.

But I do know from personal experience if you start using a lot of 32GB dimms (I think its when they are quad ranked) that the motherboard (at least my SM boards) will start clocking the speed down.
 

Sleyk

Your Friendly Knowledgable Helper and Techlover!
Mar 25, 2016
1,360
707
113
Stamford, CT
@Samir I was looking for those cheap 2 gb DIMMS just to to fill the memory banks. But I think it will not work well with the 32Gb modules.

@itronin Thanks for your info. Now I know what L means after the speed. I thought it means lower power consumption.

I just feel guilty to have only 4DIMMs installed. They looks so lonely on this giant motherboard.:D;);)
Ah yes, but they is big bois. Them 32Gb sticks are like mamma's and pappa's :.)
 
  • Like
Reactions: itronin

SRussell

Active Member
Oct 7, 2019
293
151
43
US
If you are planning on running a large amount of rotational drives several people have complained about the chassis design being insufficient in keeping all of the drives cool.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sleyk

Sleyk

Your Friendly Knowledgable Helper and Techlover!
Mar 25, 2016
1,360
707
113
Stamford, CT
If you are planning on running a large amount of rotational drives several people have complained about the chassis design being insufficient in keeping all of the drives cool.
Yeah, I've seen that too. I think its good if you can run this box in a cool place, like say a basement or maybe somewhere you can put a fan in front of it. I have 2 x 24bay supermicro chassis I have sitting in a closet. I switched to a Rosewill chassis since those cases have excellent air flow for my drives, albeit, I give up 8 bays. I can currently fit 16 drives in my Rosewill chassis, but I get airflow to all 16. I'm currently running 4TB SAS drives.

I like the Supermicro chassis, I will just wait till I get a cool place to put them, then I will load them up with all my older drives and run them both as a dump box or something.

Power bill be damned.
 

Sean Ho

seanho.com
Nov 19, 2019
505
200
43
Vancouver, BC
seanho.com
The issue is not with 32GB DIMMs per se, but that 32GB DDR3 RDIMMs are generally quad-rank, and when the MCU in Sandy/Ivy is maxed out at 8 ranks per channel (2DPC quad-rank), it clocks down to 800 MT/s. The rank limitation also means you can't fill 3DPC (e.g., X9DRi-LN4F+) with quad-rank DIMMs. It's not an issue with quad-rank LRDIMM, which presents itself as logical dual-rank.