You have proof that they have what they claim to? All the photos I got via email from them really weren't any different than what was posted here.You don't know what any of us saw? Plenty of us have spoken to him privately. This doesn't seem to concern you.
I wouldn't disqualify them so quickly just because their view isn't in your favour. We had the same thing happen last time when new people from other forums registered to post more information to complete the picture of what was going on.