I assume no POE no web management ?I bought the F1100W-4SX-4XGT for 1159 RMB (~160 USD) on Taobao. It works.
I assume no POE no web management ?I bought the F1100W-4SX-4XGT for 1159 RMB (~160 USD) on Taobao. It works.
and just by touching with a hand ? is it reaching 80-90C ?Sorry I don't have a thermal camera.
Looks like something to avoid his cat makes itself comfortable on top of his router and blocks the airflow
I'm not so sure the metal shelf helps that much with cooling since you don't have any thermal interface material between them. Two rough power coated metal surfaces don't necessarily transfer heat between them that well on their own.I currently have 4 ports plugged in. 1 using 1G, 3 using 10G. It is so hot that I can't touch it for very long. My shelf is made of steel and the switch doesn't have rubber feet so I think it helps with cooling.
I have the Hasivo S600WP-5GT-2S+_SE, which POEPLUS rebrands as S605GTP-2SX-SL. I tried to find the hottest part of the underside of the metal case with my fingers and measured it using my cheap IR thermometer. I also tried different parts of the case randomly. This gave me readings in the 45-54°C range.I was looking at the POE L3 version of this switch for futureproofing. So if I need to wall mount it this is not the switch to get due to heat? Does it have to pinholes for wall mounting underneath? I dont really need more than what the S605GTP-2SX-SL POE version offers at the moment. Should I get that instead so it dosent make a burn mark on the wall?
I'm not convinced that the 10 Gbps switch discussed here necessarily generates noticably more heat unless you run all RJ45 ports at 10 Gbps. Without measurements we really can't know though.Considering I am going to stick it to the wall then I guess S605GTP-2SX-SL will be safer?
For this case I need a managed POE switch. The FW1100 only has one managed POE version and that is the L3 one. I do not need L3. But I need to configure VLANS. I like this one for future proofing since all ports is 10G. I do not need all ports to be 10G currently. But I am skeptical due to the heat and wall mounting. Therefore I think the S605GTP-2SX-SL might be safer for wall mounting since we now know the max temp should be at 54C according to Blundens post.Not sure why you'd want an expensive L3 Switch with a dubious/sketchy Firmware. Why L3 at all ? Shouldn't you do your Main Router (and Firewall) Appliance (e.g. OPNSense) do the L3 Work so it also properly applies Firewall Rules ?
The ONTI ONT-S508CL-8S (which is apparently a rebranded XikeStor SKS8300-8X) at least has beta OpenWRT support.
Approx. 80 EUR shipped each (including VAT) for a 8xSFP+ Ports. Need to get another PSU because the Stock ones is a Public Danger !!!
The POEPLUS versions is the cheapest of the two for me. There is a cheaper one that looks the same from ONTI. But the ONTI version has way worse spec. However I am not sure we can trust any of the specs.I'm not convinced that the 10 Gbps switch discussed here necessarily generates noticably more heat unless you run all RJ45 ports at 10 Gbps. Without measurements we really can't know though.
Btw. you probably want to compare prices between the original Hasivo model S600WP-5GT-2S+_SE and the POEPLUS model you are looking at since the prices can differ quite a bit between what's essentially identical units based on sales, shipping, etc.![]()
It's mostly generic firmware from the Realtek SDK as far as I know. In my case, it's more about having the console port populated and possibly avoiding some bugs in the L2 managed interface. I don't need the L3 features, and the hardware should be the same either way. A lot of what makes it more expensive is PoE and 10 Gbps RJ45 ports, not just the management.Not sure why you'd want an expensive L3 Switch with a dubious/sketchy Firmware. Why L3 at all ? Shouldn't you do your Main Router (and Firewall) Appliance (e.g. OPNSense) do the L3 Work so it also properly applies Firewall Rules ?
The ONTI ONT-S508CL-8S (which is apparently a rebranded XikeStor SKS8300-8X) at least has beta OpenWRT support.
Approx. 80 EUR shipped each (including VAT) for a 8xSFP+ Ports. Need to get another PSU because the Stock ones is a Public Danger !!!
There is an L2 managed one called S1100W-4SX-4XGT-SE too. Hardware should presumably be the same besides not having the console cable populated.For this case I need a managed POE switch. The FW1100 only has one managed POE version and that is the L3 one. I do not need L3. But I need to configure VLANS. I like this one for future proofing since all ports is 10G. I do not need all ports to be 10G currently. But I am skeptical due to the heat and wall mounting. Therefore I think the S605GTP-2SX-SL might be safer for wall mounting since we now know the max temp should be at 54C according to Blundens post.
Ok.The POEPLUS versions is the cheapest of the two for me. There is a cheaper one that looks the same from ONTI. But the ONTI version has way worse spec. However I am not sure we can trust any of the specs.
ONT-S207CW-72TS has 80Gbits backplane and 29.76 Mpps packet forwarding.
S605GTP-2SX-SL has 160Gbits backplane and 119.04Mpps packet forwarding.
Hopefully you remembered to apply the extra $40 coupon on top of the already applied $64 discount?I actually ended up ordering the FW1100 POE L3 after chatting with Hasivo. They said it reached 50C.
That i did not... Well its to late now.Hopefully you remembered to apply the extra $40 coupon on top of the already applied $64 discount?![]()
You could always try ordering another one with the coupon code 239AS4, or whatever code they show you on the main page of AliExpress. If the first one doesn't work (seems to be an artificially limited supply of the coupon codes), you could try 139AS2 for $20 off.That i did not... Well its to late now.