Lenovo Thinkcentre/ThinkStation Tiny (Project TinyMiniMicro) Reference Thread

[cadillac]

IIRC, the first few attempts were without secureboot both win10 and win11. I confirmed that the messed up stick created by Etcher was not proper UEFI boot media, at least it did not contain the EFI partition.
@Parallax I suggest this addition to Your FAQ on the first page "With M90Q, Windows installer does not recognize Intel RST even with proper drivers supplied during install, if the boot method is not UEFI.

Also i found out that with the 65W power supply, utilizing the PCI-E slot configures the CPU to "c-TDP Down", which has negative impact on CPU performance

And to anyone considering the Mellanox Connect-X3 hardware, both the slim and "fat" PCB fits well in the unit, but beware that this NIC has no proper ASPM support in linux, and adds about 10W () to the consumption with inactive links ans also prohibits the CPU package to enter deeper sleep states than C2.

 

[Vorwrath]

Took delivery of my new P360 Tiny with an i7-12700T yesterday, so posting a few pictures and details on that in case they're helpful to anyone. I've included a couple of pictures of the PCIe riser, so hopefully somebody can work out if it's the same or different to older models (I don't have an older one to compare).

I took some idle power consumption measurements and got the following: -
Preinstalled Windows 11 desktop idle (GPU installed): 18.3w
Preinstalled Windows 11 desktop idle (after removing GPU): 10.2w
Ubuntu 22.04.1 live booted from USB stick (after removing GPU): 17.3w
Those are just measured with a TP-Link smart plug, not some scientific device, so treat them as plus/minus 10%.

Not sure why the power consumption in Ubuntu was noticeably worse. Possibly it has less power saving enabled by default, or maybe the supplied kernel is too old for good Alder Lake support.

BIOS output seemed to go to the Nvidia T400 GPU by default, so I initially couldn't get into the BIOS on the HDMI TV I was using for testing (screen was just blank until Windows booted). After removing the GPU, I did get the initial boot splash screen and BIOS output over HDMI as expected.

Another weird thing I noticed is that it kept complaining about the PSU being lower power than recommended when booting. I was just using the 170W adapter Lenovo supplied with the system, which should be more than sufficient. I suspect that is probably some kind of early BIOS bug (will have to check if there are any updates available).

I'm planning to use it as a home Proxmox server, but still want to acquire some other components first like additional RAM and an i350-T4 NIC, so won't be rolling it out for a while.

Front:

Rear:

Internals (GPU installed as supplied)

Internals (GPU removed)

NVIDIA T400 GPU and baffle

PCIe riser (front)

PCIe riser (rear)

 

[Cartwheel8704]

Interesting approach to a NAS. Do you end up with two power switches that you have to manually sequence or are you able to slave one power supply to the other?

Currently I've just got a 240v/5v molex power supply powering the enclosure, it's dumb and always on.

Currently looking at putting a simple 5v relay running off a USB port so that when power is on, the enclosure powers up.

The SATA controller I'm using supports hotswapping so this should work pretty well.

Hmm -- I just added in a Connect-Tech GPS receiver to the M.2 WiFi slot and it's not showing up in lsusb... do these still whitelist what is in the M.2 slot? AFAIK the receiver shouldn't be PCIe, just USB, so I'd expect it to show up, unless it's pulling some pins low / being kept in reset...

WIFI slots are whitelisted AFAIK. The M.2 2280 slot is not.

I believe you can get around the whitelisting by reflashing the BIOS and setting the model and serial #'s to "INVALID". More details here - https://www.reddit.com/r/Lenovo/comments/dcf0lw/_/fbpy0c5
I did this proactively, but not planning on using the WiFi slot for anything. Apparently works great (and saves fubbing about with manually editing the BIOS whitelist values).

I am also interest in making a JBOD box.
Please show us what type of cables / connectors between M.2 card to external JOBX enclosure.

I've got a full write-up on reddit here https://www.reddit.com/r/homelab/comments/xfh8p9 with pics.

In short, it's just a simple m.2>SATA controller with a JMB585 chip. I used a SEEED studio 103990543, but there's plenty of other models around. If you're looking for something more reputable, Silverstone make one, as do IO-CREST. Personally I was fine with just rolling the dice with a cheap one. From there it's just SATA cables to your enclosure.

Obviously you're going to be limited to 5x drives with this setup. If you're wanting something a bit more rock-solid, a m.2 > PCI-E > LSI HBA card should work too.

But if you're needing more than 5 drives and are going to these lengths, you should probably be looking at a full size rig (or at least an ITX). There's limits to even my crazy.

 

[Helzy]

Does anyone know the Lenovo FRU at encompass for the T400 with that proper 3 port baffle in Vorwrath's post?

 

[Occamsrazor]

This is a super-useful thread especially the table in the first post. It's interesting that the M90q Gen 2 has more storage options than the P350 (2x m.2, 1x 2.5" vs 2x m.2 only). I presume you can also put a network card in the M90q Gen 2 with a riser like the other models?
It would be great if the first post could be updated with information on the latest models i.e. M90q Gen 3 and P360....

 

[cadillac]

I have discovered that the M90Q x8 PCIE connector is also wired to the PCH...

 

[joeribl]

I have discovered that the M90Q x8 PCIE connector is also wired to the PCH...

If i look at the block diagram for the Q470 chipset, that is not strange. There are 16 lanes PCI 3.0 available straight from the CPU. And then 24 lanes from the PCH. The CPU is connected with DMI 3.0 to the PCH. Supposedly the bandwith for the DMI is 8 GT/s.

 

[cadillac]

If i look at the block diagram for the Q470 chipset, that is not strange. There are 16 lanes PCI 3.0 available straight from the CPU. And then 24 lanes from the PCH. The CPU is connected with DMI 3.0 to the PCH. Supposedly the bandwith for the DMI is 8 GT/s.

I assumed that it's wired to the CPU. This basically limits that x8 port to x4 bandwith. And it is also shared between SATA, and the two NVME ports. None of the CPU PCI-E lanes are utilized, and the offered 3 high-bandwidth expansion ports (x8,x4,x4) all share a x4 DMI uplink to the CPU which is basically x4 PCI-E bandwidth

 

[Parallax]

It would be great if the first post could be updated with information on the latest models i.e. M90q Gen 3 and P360....

I was waiting for the info to be formalised by Lenovo and (ideally) STH to review one, but I suppose I could pull the datasheet and add it in if people would like that.

 

[Parallax]

This is a super-useful thread especially the table in the first post. It's interesting that the M90q Gen 2 has more storage options than the P350 (2x m.2, 1x 2.5" vs 2x m.2 only). I presume you can also put a network card in the M90q Gen 2 with a riser like the other models?

To be honest I am not sure of the situation with the M90q Gen 2, I just know that in my P350 Tiny although the SATA port exists on the motherboard, it doesn't come with either the ZIF cable/connector for SATA or a drive caddy. There is also no FRU to buy the caddy/cable for a P350 and if you try to add the caddy it doesn't have anywhere to clip in to the fan assembly like it does on other models. And finally, there are no 2.5" drive models in the PSRef.

Could somone with an M70q/M90q Gen 2 confirm that they do come with a caddy etc?

Otherwise yes, there is an extremely hard-to-source currently riser which then allows you to deploy PCIe cards in both the M90q Gen 2 and the P350, but note we've discovered the slot is PCIe 3 and not 4, no idea why.

 

[Parallax]

Took delivery of my new P360 Tiny with an i7-12700T yesterday, so posting a few pictures and details on that in case they're helpful to anyone. I've included a couple of pictures of the PCIe riser, so hopefully somebody can work out if it's the same or different to older models (I don't have an older one to compare).

It's a different part number (the M90q Gen 2/P350 Tiny one is 5C50W00877) so I would say it is different and presumably supports PCIe 4.

 

[Parallax]

So, I am shocked that the max SSD storage is spec'd as 250GB and max M.2 SSD as 1 TB ... I am also curious as to why this might be the case.

Is this still accurate ? Has anyone put these limitations to test ?

I think that's more to do with the max configuration available at the time from Lenovo. I have tried a 4TB SSD and 2TB NVMe drive with no issues.

 

[Parallax]

Apologies all for a long quiet period - I was on holiday without internet access for a couple of weeks. I'll try to get some time this weekend to update the main post.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

I just got my m90q Gen1 i9-10900 and PNY T1000 8 GB GPU (normal fan model - not Lenovo custom heat pipe version). Additional required part was 5C50W00877 PCIe 3.0 x16 riser and 5M10U50348 bezel to give some support at the rear of the card. Would be doable with only the riser.

I played a bit of CS:GO (Auto:High settings @ 1440p) with FPS ranging roughly between 60 and 120.

Thermals rise quite fast to the thermal limits of both CPU and GPU. Logically full power CPU didn't come near to it's power limit while the 50 W GPU throttled from either power or thermals.

Despite thermal throttling the gaming experience was nice however I will try to figure out could there be some way to make the components more efficient. As far as I know there is no way to undervolt Intel 10th gen CPUs anymore but perhaps there is something that can be done to the T1000. I'm not doing any professional work on the machine so some rare instability is acceptable.

Starting gaming:


While gaming:

 

[Occamsrazor]

It's a different part number (the M90q Gen 2/P350 Tiny one is 5C50W00877) so I would say it is different and presumably supports PCIe 4.

A search for the FRU 5c50w00910 that Vorwrath has in the P360 finds these, in case it's of use to anyone:

NEW PCIE16 Riser Expansion Graphic Card for ThinkStation P360 tiny8 5C50W00910 615284541868 | eBay

Find many great new & used options and get the best deals for NEW PCIE16 Riser Expansion Graphic Card for ThinkStation P360 tiny8 5C50W00910 at the best online prices at eBay! Free shipping for many products!

www.ebay.com

Lenovo 5C50W00910 CARDPOP BLD Tiny8 PCIex16 Riser card - sparepartworld.com

Lenovo 5C50W00910 CARDPOP BLD Tiny8 PCIex16 Riser card • Original Lenovo Notebook PCB Boards online bestellen

www.sparepartworld.com

 

[Wasmachineman_NL]

I just got my m90q Gen1 i9-10900 and PNY T1000 8 GB GPU (normal fan model - not Lenovo custom heat pipe version). Additional required part was 5C50W00877 PCIe 3.0 x16 riser and 5M10U50348 bezel to give some support at the rear of the card. Would be doable with only the riser.

I played a bit of CS:GO (Auto:High settings @ 1440p) with FPS ranging roughly between 60 and 120.

Thermals rise quite fast to the thermal limits of both CPU and GPU. Logically full power CPU didn't come near to it's power limit while the 50 W GPU throttled from either power or thermals.

Despite thermal throttling the gaming experience was nice however I will try to figure out could there be some way to make the components more efficient. As far as I know there is no way to undervolt Intel 10th gen CPUs anymore but perhaps there is something that can be done to the T1000. I'm not doing any professional work on the machine so some rare instability is acceptable.

Starting gaming:
View attachment 24734

While gaming:
View attachment 24735

Could try ThrottleStop to undervolt.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

It's a different part number (the M90q Gen 2/P350 Tiny one is 5C50W00877) so I would say it is different and presumably supports PCIe 4.

M90q Gen 1/P340 and Gen 2/P350 share the 5C50W00877 riser. Gen 1/P340 has Q370 chipset whereas Gen 2/P350 has Q470 chipset but both chipsets support only PCIe 3.
M90q Gen 3/P360 on the other hand has Q670 chipset which supports PCIe 4 (also PCIe 3). It would be quite insane for the riser to be PCIe 3 but I could not find any details about it.

 

[TonyTheTiger]

Could try ThrottleStop to undervolt.

In up-to-date Intel 6-10th gen CPU machines undervolt is supposedly blocked by CPU microcode and/or BIOS. On my system it looks like that - or at least all voltage adjustments are greyed out in Throttlestop. Turbo power limits seemed to be the only variables to play with. Supposedly BIOS can be downgraded to an older version where undervolting is not blocked but the Intel microcode change is supposed to be irreversible.

 

[Wasmachineman_NL]

In up-to-date Intel 6-10th gen CPU machines undervolt is supposedly blocked by CPU microcode and/or BIOS. On my system it looks like that - or at least all voltage adjustments are greyed out in Throttlestop. Turbo power limits seemed to be the only variables to play with. Supposedly BIOS can be downgraded to an older version where undervolting is not blocked but the Intel microcode change is supposed to be irreversible.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Lenovo/comments/id0457

 

[Parallax]

For folks in the UK looking for a M90q/Gen 2/P340/P350 PCIe riser, there's one on eBay for £20 + shipping.

I bought four from China, which averaged out at about £35 each after shipping so this is a good price, especially as nowhere else seems to have stock.