EU ATP X4C16QE8BNRCSE-7-LI1 16GB DDR4-2400 UDIMM ECC - Probably Samsung DRAM Chip

[Cruzader]

like @Cruzader is arguing.

I have not argued anything, just saying i already know they got multiple teams.

Wanting you to pay full/wrong shipping and then refund sounds like a bad idea since taking payment fees on the incoming and to then refund the full amount out.

Id understand that more if coming through their store, since they could just adjust the card reservation to the correct before its charged.
(But still not practical when it comes to extra steps)

When i order from them the shipping cost is also horrible before its adjusted, the last servers i ordered was like 2400€ before they combined shipping to 299€.
Id never pay before they adjust it.

 

[b3rrytech]

Just a follow up for me as well. I ended up withdrawing my offer and instead opt to ship to my Mailboxde address in Germany. I found a few other things in Germany to buy so I figured that'll make everything easier. Plus, when ordering through ebay.de instead of ebay.com or ebay.co.uk you get the discount if you buy multiple sticks. I ended up buing 11 sticks total to even out my previous purchases. Fingers crossed they work as planned. But I do have more confidence in Micron parts than Samsung for some reason so I'm positive.

(Also, yes I changed username since last post)

 

[luckylinux]

They again rejected the same Offer 24 x Samsung-Chip that I originally made at 15 EUR / each.

This starts to look like a Company run by Danish Schizophrenic Politicians .

On the other Hand, I received the 24 DIMMs that I originally ordered and paid for (approx. 16 EUR / Piece including Shipping, AKA 24x15 EUR + 20 EUR Shipping from DE to DK).

 

[luckylinux]

But I do have more confidence in Micron parts than Samsung for some reason so I'm positive.

Funny I had (a few) more Issues with Micron in the Past. SK Hynix or Samsung quite good most of the Time.

And Thanks for the Tip about Mailboxde. Actually it would be 10 EUR to ship to Denmark and like 3 EUR extra for Handling, which seems VERY GOOD.

EDIT 1: actually MailBoxDE has some worring Bad Reviews, even if the Average is Good: Mailboxde wird auf Trustpilot mit 4,5 von 5 als „Hervorragend“ bewertet

 

[b3rrytech]

Funny I had (a few) more Issues with Micron in the Past. SK Hynix or Samsung quite good most of the Time.

And Thanks for the Tip about Mailboxde. Actually it would be 10 EUR to ship to Denmark and like 3 EUR extra for Handling, which seems VERY GOOD.

EDIT 1: actually MailBoxDE has some worring Bad Reviews, even if the Average is Good: Mailboxde wird auf Trustpilot mit 4,5 von 5 als „Hervorragend“ bewertet

I've used Mailboxde multiple times to Sweden and Norway in the past with no problem. Every company will have bad reviews once they've been in business long enough and grew enough. I wouldn't read too much into it. Like, do you write a positive review every time you're satisfied?! Trustpilot is of course heavily leaning to negative reviews since those are the ones most likely to say anything.

 

[luckylinux]

I've used Mailboxde multiple times to Sweden and Norway in the past with no problem. Every company will have bad reviews once they've been in business long enough and grew enough. I wouldn't read too much into it. Like, do you write a positive review every time you're satisfied?! Trustpilot is of course heavily leaning to negative reviews since those are the ones most likely to say anything.

I don't understand why they accepted the Offer before and now they keep declining. I guess they wanted some Free Advertisement and now Junked Up Prices and don't give a Damn about anything that could require a bit extra Work.

Like, do you write a positive review every time you're satisfied?! Trustpilot is of course heavily leaning to negative reviews since those are the ones most likely to say anything.

I know but still ....

I'd prefer avoiding to Risk it when we talk 400 EUR or so. And they Shipped the first Order without Issues.

 

[luckylinux]

We can apparently also try to send Offers from their own Website:

ATP 16GB DDR4-2400 ECC X4C16QE8BNRCME-E-LI1 für Server ASRock - Piospartslap

ATP ATP 16GB DDR4-2400 ECC X4C16QE8BNRCME-E-LI1 für Server ASRock Technical Data / Technische Daten Manufacturer / Hersteller ATP Type /

www.piospartslap.de

ATP 16GB DDR4-2400 ECC X4C16QE8BNRCSE-7-LI1 für Server ASRock - Piospartslap

ATP ATP 16GB DDR4-2400 ECC X4C16QW8BNRCSE-7-LI1 für Server ASRock Technical Data / Technische Daten Manufacturer / Hersteller ATP Type /

www.piospartslap.de

I just tried to submit them an Offer via their Website instead. I mean, eBay prevents me from sending any Offer to the Micron-Type anymore since I already got rejected 3 Times.

 

[luckylinux]

SUCCESS: within 15 Minutes they accepted my Offer through their Website.

14 EUR / DIMM.

Not huge Discount (especially considering that they adjusted for VAT: 14.7 EUR / DIMM, so the same as before basically) but I guess better take some more while I still can ... I told them in a Comment that they can choose which one to send, either Micron or Samsung, I don't care too much to be honest ...

 

[gb00s]

SUCCESS: within 15 Minutes they accepted my Offer through their Website.

14 EUR / DIMM.

I did that as well. Rejected. So it's personal. Poor guys. Greeks. With all the experience with Cypriots and Greeks, I should have known better.

 

[luckylinux]

I did that as well. Rejected. So it's personal. Poor guys. Greeks. With all the experience with Cypriots and Greeks, I should have known better.

Well they rejected me lots of Time on eBay too ... It was driving me Crazy.

Maybe I could have saved some more but I guess it is what it is ... Still an amazingly good Deal IMHO. To think that I paid 24 EUR / DIMM 2 Weeks ago or so .

 

[AlexGee]

One general question: what are you doing with so many RAM sticks?

As these are used in consumer boards with max 4 RAM slots, your max is „just“ 64GB…
I did not try to buy these UDIMMs for my MC12-LE0, which I bought from piospartlab…
32GB ECC UDIMMs would have been nice

 

[luckylinux]

One general question: what are you doing with so many RAM sticks?

As these are used in consumer boards with max 4 RAM slots, your max is „just“ 64GB…
I did not try to buy these UDIMMs for my MC12-LE0, which I bought from piospartlab…
32GB ECC UDIMMs would have been nice

Sure but it's a whole other Price then for 32GB UDIMMs ...

And I'm coming from the E3 v3 Platform so going from 32GB to 64GB is quite an Upgrade.

But right now there seems to be a general Issue with the ASROCK Rack B450D4U-V1LQ5 which does NOT support ECC UDIMMs when used with AMD Ryzen 5000 Gen.

Well, worst case I could upgrade from Xeon E3 v3 to Xeon E3 v6 with something like a Fujitsu TX1320 M3 which is very cheap, then sell of all my Xeon E3 v3 (and also E3 v2) Systems.

 

[AlexGee]

If I wouldn’t have 4x16GB ECC UDIMMs before, I would have bought these for my budget backup server:

Gigabyte MC12-LE0 - 33€
Ryzen 3500X - 40€
16GB Optane M10 from AliExpress (for OS) - 5€
4x16GB ECC from here - 56€

 

[azee]

My offer of 17 euro each for 4 pieces was accepted but at checkout shipping cost is at 80 euro, i send them couple of request for combined shipping but no answer yet.

my shipping price was adjust to 20 euro from 80.
and today morning i received my 4 sticks.