Yup, CPU SOC for CPU 2 is only at 0.6v according to the BMC. However, I'm using an EVGA 1200 P2 Supernova, which should be fine. Contacting Asrock Rack with these questions as well.
Both cpus seem to post just fine in socket 0 with 256GBs of RAM. Switching RAM sticks had no effect. (That was a quick swap, I know zac!)
Steps also included blasting the shit out of the cpu socket with a 500W dust blaster to get rid of any potential dust and wiping the cpus down to no avail. No bent pins in either socket.