Storage spaces mirror fault tolerance vs raid 10

Discussion in 'Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization' started by OnSeATer, Aug 10, 2018.

  1. OnSeATer

    OnSeATer New Member

    Joined:
    Jul 31, 2016
    Messages:
    15
    Likes Received:
    0
    Hi ... on the off chance that anyone is following this thread or comes across it on a google search I wanted to post a quick followup.

    Did a proof of concept consisting of:

    - "Performance tier" of 2x Intel S3500 SSDs, directly connected over SATA
    - "Capacity tier" of 2x HP HDD, configured as a single RAID1 logical volume behind the LSI raid controller on a Supermicro X9DRD board

    The MediaType of the LSI Raid logical volume was set to HDD using the Set-PhysicalDisk command.

    On the Performance tier, the ResiliencySettingName was set to Mirror
    On the Capacity tier, the ResiliencySettingName was set to Simple (which it had to be, since Windows only sees the one logical drive)

    A windows volume was created via New-Volume, using tiers, with ReFS as the filesystem.

    Performance on CrystalDiskMark on this new volume was consistent with the performance of 2x S3500 SSDs, suggesting that things were more or less working as expected. I have not yet done any more detailed testing / benchmarking but was sufficiently encouraged that I am moving ahead with this approach at a somewhat larger scale with NVMe drives as the Performance tier and a Raid 6 array of HDDs as the Capacity tier. Happy to post updates if anyone is interested.
     
    #21
  2. Connorise

    Connorise Member

    Joined:
    Mar 2, 2017
    Messages:
    58
    Likes Received:
    11
    >My thought had been that this would provide fault tolerance comparable to RAID 10 ... worst case tolerating 1 failure, best case tolerating 4 failures. But in doing more reading it seems that no matter how many columns, mirrored storage spaces won't tolerate more than one drive failure.

    Not rly, SS will provide you with "like" RAID 10 replication. In reality, SS in the 8HDDs configuration will be able to tolerate 1 drive failure and not more. On the other hand, HW will provide you with possibility to lose 4 drives (if you are lucky enough)
     
    #22
Similar Threads: Storage spaces
Forum Title Date
Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization Anyone Configure Virtual Machine Manager for Storage Spaces Direct? Jun 19, 2018
Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization Performance Storage Spaces 2-way-mirror with SAS-SSD-JBODs Jun 3, 2018
Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization Storage Spaces issues (BSODs on writes plus "consider replacing drive" message) Apr 4, 2018
Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization Simple RAID0/Stripe using Windows Storage Spaces on Windows Server 2016/1709 very slow? Jan 18, 2018
Windows Server, Hyper-V Virtualization Storage Spaces (Server2016) with lots of disks Nov 25, 2017

Share This Page