Hello everyone, I'm building a new house and I try to decide for Brocade ICX6610-48P or Ruckus Brocade ICX7450-48P or two 24 ports switches connected eachother (PoE and not-PoE)
I know that my question is already present al lot of time in this forum, but I didn't find the right answer.
My needs are:
- POE+ ports for APs, VOIP Adapters, IP Cameras, maybe POE Lighting system with sensors, Video Entryphone and any other device that I can connect (also with PoE splitter) by wire instead of WIFI
- Three 10GB (without redundancy, if not 2x) and 17 1Gb connections to my little cluster (3 esxi box, 1 nas) and my workstation that stay in a room 28 meter away (with 10base-t transceiver)
- 16 1GB devices (PCs, RPIs, AV Receiver, Video Projector, TV, SAT->IP...)
- Dual PSU protected by UPS to prevent any possible downtime for critical devices (Alarm, Camera IP, Door Bell, Video Entryphone and so on)
- when I will go to live in, a big media center (now I'm using Emby on my Workstation, but it is full of HDDs) like this one: 4U 24 Bay SAS3 Vmware Storage Server X10QBi Includes CPU/Memory
- power wattage is not a a problem
- noise is not a problem (I will dedicate a room in basement)
My concern is about the pro and cons between the two units:
ICX 6xxx is EoL and ICX7xxx is supported, so it means that the first one had the last firmware, while the latter will have new firmware for much time (now 9.0).
But is the new firmware a worth update? Which new features does it have?
ICX7xxx seems to have less port 10GB or 40 GB ports. ICX6xxx have a lot more SFP+ and QSFP+ ports
ICX7xxx have PoH support (90W), but I didn't find a device that use it. Also the last Wifi 6 Ap uses the PoE+ standard. Anyone could give me a list of these devices?
ICX6xxx vs ICX7xxx reliability and durability over time. (I wish to use it for many years)
.
So, I ask everyone to convince me which one is the best or alternative options (Brocade or other brand with similar performance).
I'm not in hurry, because the house will be ready and the end on the year
Thank you very much
I know that my question is already present al lot of time in this forum, but I didn't find the right answer.
My needs are:
- POE+ ports for APs, VOIP Adapters, IP Cameras, maybe POE Lighting system with sensors, Video Entryphone and any other device that I can connect (also with PoE splitter) by wire instead of WIFI
- Three 10GB (without redundancy, if not 2x) and 17 1Gb connections to my little cluster (3 esxi box, 1 nas) and my workstation that stay in a room 28 meter away (with 10base-t transceiver)
- 16 1GB devices (PCs, RPIs, AV Receiver, Video Projector, TV, SAT->IP...)
- Dual PSU protected by UPS to prevent any possible downtime for critical devices (Alarm, Camera IP, Door Bell, Video Entryphone and so on)
- when I will go to live in, a big media center (now I'm using Emby on my Workstation, but it is full of HDDs) like this one: 4U 24 Bay SAS3 Vmware Storage Server X10QBi Includes CPU/Memory
- power wattage is not a a problem
- noise is not a problem (I will dedicate a room in basement)
My concern is about the pro and cons between the two units:
ICX 6xxx is EoL and ICX7xxx is supported, so it means that the first one had the last firmware, while the latter will have new firmware for much time (now 9.0).
But is the new firmware a worth update? Which new features does it have?
ICX7xxx seems to have less port 10GB or 40 GB ports. ICX6xxx have a lot more SFP+ and QSFP+ ports
ICX7xxx have PoH support (90W), but I didn't find a device that use it. Also the last Wifi 6 Ap uses the PoE+ standard. Anyone could give me a list of these devices?
ICX6xxx vs ICX7xxx reliability and durability over time. (I wish to use it for many years)
.
So, I ask everyone to convince me which one is the best or alternative options (Brocade or other brand with similar performance).
I'm not in hurry, because the house will be ready and the end on the year
Thank you very much
Last edited: