Minisforum MS-01 PCIe Card and RAM Compatibility Thread

Notice: Page may contain affiliate links for which we may earn a small commission through services like Amazon Affiliates or Skimlinks.
Hi guys,

I would like some advice. I will use a pon optical module to replace my internet box directly in ms-01 and I don't want to risk to plug in directly in sfp ports because it's very hot.

So I prefer to use a pcie card for that. In your opinion, which single sfp 10g port card will be the more efficient and cooler without doing cooling mods in the ms-01 case?
What makes you think it will be cooler? I always thought that the heat is mostly from the modules plugged into the SFP+ cage, not the underlying X710 or whatever. Modules for RJ45 10GbaseT get very hot, but optical modules less so.
 
What makes you think it will be cooler? I always thought that the heat is mostly from the modules plugged into the SFP+ cage, not the underlying X710 or whatever. Modules for RJ45 10GbaseT get very hot, but optical modules less so.

I don't necessarily think it will be cooler, but pcie card is replaceable easily, motherboard is more complicated. It's a xgs-pon module that run on a basis of 65°C because it includes a kind micro CPU and RAM.
 
I got my last 4+2 switch for $16 delivered & it uses 1W idle. If you're really worried about isolation then why not run a DAC to one SFP+ port and plug your module into the other?
As it receives the fiber, I need to configure the interface with vlan and dhcp from internet provider in opnsense. I don't think I can do it via a switch
 
@herbie Couple of things:
  1. In general, client side PON modules burn roughly the same amount of juice as standard optics. The only difference in the tech has to do with how the multiple endpoints are bundled together at the ISP side and at the splitter sites along the poles. (yes this is a super simplification and there are other differences, but w/e). Certain XGPON modules do burn 2W, which is twice the normal amount, but they are super rare on the client side.
  2. DACs, AOCs, and optics are all within spec for the MS-01's onboard SFP+ ports as they all operate within that same ≤1W power envelope. 10GBase-T SFP+ are more of the edge case that most chassis were never designed for (there are other types of SFP+ modules that burn more than >1W also, but they're super niche.) I'd still recommend checking the data sheet if you're worried
  3. There is no active cooling in the MS-01 other than the CPU fan. If you use a 10G or higher pcie card that isn't optimized for passive cooling without active airflow, your card will be the issue, not the module (e.g trying to use a passive Mellanox CX3/CX4 card, or a passive X520/X710). In general, 10G SFP+ cards consume 5W-10W, so in an enclosed space, they need either an active cooling solution (heatsink with a fan) or active airflow like in a server chassis.
  4. If your PON links at ≤10Gbps, then media converters in general are the go-to for any heat mitigation as they move the tranciever to a separate box. TP-Link converters are currently my favorite as they have both 10GBase-T to SFP+ as well as SFP+ to SFP+ and are pretty low cost, way cheaper than an equivilant switch. If your PON links at ≤1G then the media converters then they're basically a rounding error. For the MS-01, you would use an SFP+ to SFP+ converter, and place the PON module in one port, and probably a DAC in the other one, but will depend on whether you have a GPON or XGPON uplink.
  5. There is a way to use a switch in a PON-based PPPoE link path, however it takes a fair bit of effort to set up if you've never done it before and don't know how switches work, so I'd stay away from that approach if you're new to that world (if you're using a PON and VLAN tagging, it sounds like you're probably going to have a username & password based PPPoE link back to the CO)
So yea, just check the data sheet for the module, but you should be fine to use the onboard SFP+ ports with the PON module.
 
  • Like
Reactions: nicoska
@herbie Couple of things:
  1. In general, client side PON modules burn roughly the same amount of juice as standard optics. The only difference in the tech has to do with how the multiple endpoints are bundled together at the ISP side and at the splitter sites along the poles. (yes this is a super simplification and there are other differences, but w/e). Certain XGPON modules do burn 2W, which is twice the normal amount, but they are super rare on the client side.
  2. DACs, AOCs, and optics are all within spec for the MS-01's onboard SFP+ ports as they all operate within that same ≤1W power envelope. 10GBase-T SFP+ are more of the edge case that most chassis were never designed for (there are other types of SFP+ modules that burn more than >1W also, but they're super niche.) I'd still recommend checking the data sheet if you're worried
  3. There is no active cooling in the MS-01 other than the CPU fan. If you use a 10G or higher pcie card that isn't optimized for passive cooling without active airflow, your card will be the issue, not the module (e.g trying to use a passive Mellanox CX3/CX4 card, or a passive X520/X710). In general, 10G SFP+ cards consume 5W-10W, so in an enclosed space, they need either an active cooling solution (heatsink with a fan) or active airflow like in a server chassis.
  4. If your PON links at ≤10Gbps, then media converters in general are the go-to for any heat mitigation as they move the tranciever to a separate box. TP-Link converters are currently my favorite as they have both 10GBase-T to SFP+ as well as SFP+ to SFP+ and are pretty low cost, way cheaper than an equivilant switch. If your PON links at ≤1G then the media converters then they're basically a rounding error. For the MS-01, you would use an SFP+ to SFP+ converter, and place the PON module in one port, and probably a DAC in the other one, but will depend on whether you have a GPON or XGPON uplink.
  5. There is a way to use a switch in a PON-based PPPoE link path, however it takes a fair bit of effort to set up if you've never done it before and don't know how switches work, so I'd stay away from that approach if you're new to that world (if you're using a PON and VLAN tagging, it sounds like you're probably going to have a username & password based PPPoE link back to the CO)
So yea, just check the data sheet for the module, but you should be fine to use the onboard SFP+ ports with the PON module.
Thanks @bryan_v , here are specs of my xgs-pon if you want to have a look:
XGSPON ONU STICK SFP+ Transceiver SC/APC Receptacle
* Single fiber bi-directional data links symmetric TX 9.953 Gb/s / RX 9.953 Gb/s with MAC function
* SFP package with SC/APC receptacle
* Single 3.3 V power supply
* Hot-pluggable capability
* High power 1270 nm DML DFB LD and high sensitivity 1577 nm APD
* Support 20 km transmission distance with SMF
* CML compatible data input/output interface
* Low power dissipation < 2.5 W
* Low EMI and excellent ESD protection
* Digital diagnostic monitor interface
* RoHS-6 compliance
* Support of GPON/XGS-PON/NGPON2 standards
* 256 GEM/XGEM ports, 64 T-CONTs or 16 LLIDs
* Carrier Grade QoS Engine
* Advanced loopback and diagnostic capabilities
* Supports Synchronous Ethernet (SyncE)
* Case temperature range:
Commercial: 0°C ~ 70°C
Industrial: -40°C ~ +85°C
* MAC IC: Maxlinear PRX126

According specs, do you think it will be ok to put the module in sfp port of ms-01?

Or as the module is xgs-pon and simulate the internet provider box with virtual serial number and stuff. Do you think it will work with media converter ?
 
Last edited:
Yeup, that's a high power XGSPON transceiver. I assume there is also a heatsink on the transceiver as well? The transceiver would probably also be significantly longer than a normal transceiver. (2.5W is the danger zone if there's no heatsink)

Depending on which generational revision the transceiver is from, it might be expecting active airflow over the optics section. Switches and business class routers normally maintain negative pressure in the chassis, causing air to be pulled in through all the ports (thus causing airflow over the optics). If however the original ISP box didn't have active cooling, then it's probably designed to passively dissipate heat and all you'll have to do is make sure the surrounding environment stays around STP and there is headspace for convection to carry the heat away, but in general it will be fine in your MS-01's SFP+ (though the heatsink might block the pcie slot).

If you're still worried, you can grab a Klein or Fluke multimeter with a thermocouple and just double check the temps, they're useful to have around anyways. As long as the SFP+ cage inside the MS-01 <55C, you're fine. If the temps push past 60C you'll need some active airflow somewhere as you probably have a heat pocket forming behind or inside the case. Or alternatively at that point, you can also grab a 10G media converter, which will push that heat to an external box that you can mount on the wall where natural convection will help cool it (also helps keep the APC stuff out of the rack).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scott Laird
Also, while 2.5W is a lot for a tiny SFP, it's a trivial amount of heat to cool with any fan at all. I have a few MS-01s with 120mm USB fans just sitting on top of the case blowing air down through the top vent holes, and they all run dramatically cooler than they would otherwise. That's more than enough to keep a ~25W ConnectX-5 happy. Adding pretty much any fan at all would probably keep a 2.5W SFP cool without much trouble or much noise.
 
Yeup, that's a high power XGSPON transceiver. I assume there is also a heatsink on the transceiver as well? The transceiver would probably also be significantly longer than a normal transceiver. (2.5W is the danger zone if there's no heatsink)

Depending on which generational revision the transceiver is from, it might be expecting active airflow over the optics section. Switches and business class routers normally maintain negative pressure in the chassis, causing air to be pulled in through all the ports (thus causing airflow over the optics). If however the original ISP box didn't have active cooling, then it's probably designed to passively dissipate heat and all you'll have to do is make sure the surrounding environment stays around STP and there is headspace for convection to carry the heat away, but in general it will be fine in your MS-01's SFP+ (though the heatsink might block the pcie slot).

If you're still worried, you can grab a Klein or Fluke multimeter with a thermocouple and just double check the temps, they're useful to have around anyways. As long as the SFP+ cage inside the MS-01 <55C, you're fine. If the temps push past 60C you'll need some active airflow somewhere as you probably have a heat pocket forming behind or inside the case. Or alternatively at that point, you can also grab a 10G media converter, which will push that heat to an external box that you can mount on the wall where natural convection will help cool it (also helps keep the APC stuff out of the rack).

To protect the ms-01 ports, is it a good idea to use this kind of switch with added heat dissipators on the xgs-pon module, plug the module inside and use a dac cable to ms-01 ?
1763998161580.png
 
Don't use a switch, use a media converter. If you use a switch, you need to have management functions so you can set it up as either a virtual wire, or configure the two ports properly to forward PPPoE packets to each other (not hard, but not trivial either), at which point you've wasted so much money you might as well get a dedicated box with proper cooling. This is an example of SFP+ to 10Base-T, but you might want a SFP+ to SFP+ if you want to completely bypass your ISP's hardware.
 
Don't use a switch, use a media converter. If you use a switch, you need to have management functions so you can set it up as either a virtual wire, or configure the two ports properly to forward PPPoE packets to each other (not hard, but not trivial either), at which point you've wasted so much money you might as well get a dedicated box with proper cooling. This is an example of SFP+ to 10Base-T, but you might want a SFP+ to SFP+ if you want to completely bypass your ISP's hardware.

In fact, there is no need for pppoe. It is juste vlan tagging that can be done on xgs module or opensense and it's pure dhcp
 
If they're not using PPPoE then yea, you're fine; though pure DHCP is pretty unusual because it has no protection for rouge endpoints just spicing into the network at a pole and spoofing a mac because it's just a passive network. Have you done a dry run with an homebrew box?
 
@bryan_v I already tested xgs-pon directly in sfp router and it works fine, but never tested with switch or media converter in between. For the xgs-pon to work, we have to put serial number of original provider box and imei number, and the module appears as legitimate to receive public ip.
 
@bryan_v I already tested xgs-pon directly in sfp router and it works fine, but never tested with switch or media converter in between. For the xgs-pon to work, we have to put serial number of original provider box and imei number, and the module appears as legitimate to receive public ip.

Hello,
out of curiosity, which provider are you talking about? I'm asking because I'm in Italy and I'm interested about this option.
Currently I'm using a 10G fritzbox to connect to my 10Gbs provider, but I'd love to bypass it and use Opnsense in my MS-A2 box.
thanks
 
Hello,
out of curiosity, which provider are you talking about? I'm asking because I'm in Italy and I'm interested about this option.
Currently I'm using a 10G fritzbox to connect to my 10Gbs provider, but I'd love to bypass it and use Opnsense in my MS-A2 box.
thanks
Using Bouygues french provider but you may find your ISP on pon.wiki
 
If you've tested it in a home-built box, then you should be fine. If you're running 8311 on the transceiver itself, then the layer 2-ish auth is S/N and RegID. You should still keep an eye on Layer 3, especially if Bouygues issues IPv6 addresses, but in general, a dumb switch or a media converter will both work.

Also just saw the transceiver on pon.wiki, and yes that heatsink looks really small for XGS and is probably designed for active airflow, or at least headspace above for convection to cool the optics. Since it runs linux, once you have it set up, you should see if you can get temperature data from the PRX126. If you can access the die temp, just set up a batch script to poll it every 1-5 min and feed that to a timescale db (Prometheus probably, but anything will really work). If it peaks over 60C, just point a fan at it (5V USB powered arctic/delta/sunon/noctua would do the trick), try pushing cold air into the router room.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Scott Laird
There is a very active community on discord discussing XGSPON, link is at the pon.wiki site. I am tempted to bypass my Frontier FRX523 but 1) I'm not clear on the advantage, I already get 2.5 Gbps up/down and 5 ms pings to my closest DNS (9.9.9.9) on my 2 Gbps plan. How much better can it get? And 2) with tariffs the XGSPON's have become quite expensive. There is a seller on alliexpress that ships from the US and it includes a tiny heatsink and fan, but still $125+
 
Confirming for anyone else searching. I got the above Glotrends card along with this m.2 adapter working with the DEG1:
https://www.aliexpress.us/item/3256807419018300.html

I'm looking to use my MS-01 and the above items + DEG1 as a temporary solution to play Arc Raiders when I go on travel, so I'm hoping it works well.

What GPU did you end up using the DEG1? I've read some posts elsewhere about issues with Nvidia GPUs.