@herbie Couple of things:
- In general, client side PON modules burn roughly the same amount of juice as standard optics. The only difference in the tech has to do with how the multiple endpoints are bundled together at the ISP side and at the splitter sites along the poles. (yes this is a super simplification and there are other differences, but w/e). Certain XGPON modules do burn 2W, which is twice the normal amount, but they are super rare on the client side.
- DACs, AOCs, and optics are all within spec for the MS-01's onboard SFP+ ports as they all operate within that same ≤1W power envelope. 10GBase-T SFP+ are more of the edge case that most chassis were never designed for (there are other types of SFP+ modules that burn more than >1W also, but they're super niche.) I'd still recommend checking the data sheet if you're worried
- There is no active cooling in the MS-01 other than the CPU fan. If you use a 10G or higher pcie card that isn't optimized for passive cooling without active airflow, your card will be the issue, not the module (e.g trying to use a passive Mellanox CX3/CX4 card, or a passive X520/X710). In general, 10G SFP+ cards consume 5W-10W, so in an enclosed space, they need either an active cooling solution (heatsink with a fan) or active airflow like in a server chassis.
- If your PON links at ≤10Gbps, then media converters in general are the go-to for any heat mitigation as they move the tranciever to a separate box. TP-Link converters are currently my favorite as they have both 10GBase-T to SFP+ as well as SFP+ to SFP+ and are pretty low cost, way cheaper than an equivilant switch. If your PON links at ≤1G then the media converters then they're basically a rounding error. For the MS-01, you would use an SFP+ to SFP+ converter, and place the PON module in one port, and probably a DAC in the other one, but will depend on whether you have a GPON or XGPON uplink.
- There is a way to use a switch in a PON-based PPPoE link path, however it takes a fair bit of effort to set up if you've never done it before and don't know how switches work, so I'd stay away from that approach if you're new to that world (if you're using a PON and VLAN tagging, it sounds like you're probably going to have a username & password based PPPoE link back to the CO)
So yea, just check the data sheet for the module, but you should be fine to use the onboard SFP+ ports with the PON module.
Thanks
@bryan_v , here are specs of my xgs-pon if you want to have a look:
XGSPON ONU STICK SFP+ Transceiver SC/APC Receptacle
* Single fiber bi-directional data links symmetric TX 9.953 Gb/s / RX 9.953 Gb/s with MAC function
* SFP package with SC/APC receptacle
* Single 3.3 V power supply
* Hot-pluggable capability
* High power 1270 nm DML DFB LD and high sensitivity 1577 nm APD
* Support 20 km transmission distance with SMF
* CML compatible data input/output interface
* Low power dissipation < 2.5 W
* Low EMI and excellent ESD protection
* Digital diagnostic monitor interface
* RoHS-6 compliance
* Support of GPON/XGS-PON/NGPON2 standards
* 256 GEM/XGEM ports, 64 T-CONTs or 16 LLIDs
* Carrier Grade QoS Engine
* Advanced loopback and diagnostic capabilities
* Supports Synchronous Ethernet (SyncE)
* Case temperature range:
Commercial: 0°C ~ 70°C
Industrial: -40°C ~ +85°C
* MAC IC: Maxlinear PRX126
According specs, do you think it will be ok to put the module in sfp port of ms-01?
Or as the module is xgs-pon and simulate the internet provider box with virtual serial number and stuff. Do you think it will work with media converter ?