@Leondre and @Weapon which ECC Ram are you using?
I used Kingston 32GB ECC modules.
And I had absolutely no problems with Supermicro but I had trouble with Asus W680.
I had two different 13700K.
With the Supermicro-Board I got every combination of CPU with RAM modules to run.
The Asus Board...
Everyone with a 13900K in this thread is okay with ASUS W680 and ECC and everyone 13700K and slower has trouble.
I think this is because of silicon lottery.
I hope that ASUS is able to fix this in the new firmware.
ECC is a demanding task for the memory controller.
For future servers I think...
You need to have DDR5 ECC and one DDR5 non ECC at hand.
Because if you boot into a bad combination you simply replace the ECC with the non ECC and you are able to boot again.
You can orientate yourself with CL tRCD tRP tRAS because there is a one-to-one mapping between the Asus BIOS and this...
This one seems to have even more room:
Fractal Design Define 7 XL Black TG Light Tint ab € 207,22 (2023) | Preisvergleich Geizhals Deutschland
When you count the number of maximum PCIe cards
Silverstone Seta Q1 has 7 slot placeholder
Fractal design has 9 slot placeholder
so more room for the...
The Silverstone SETA Q1 mentions SSI EEB
I built a system with Asus WS 680 and there was plenty of room in every direction
https://www.silverstonetek.com/en/product/info/computer-chassis/SETAQ1/
The Asus W680 was really tricky to setup.
I basically read out the subtimings of the X13SAE and set this timings on the Asus W680 BIOS
And afterwards I had memorycorrection 5
It is now a Windows Server 2022 machine and working really fine.
The X13SAE is now my developer machine (both the...
@Styp
Sorry for being a little late.
But can you tell me your CPU?
AFAIK you need a 13900 / 13700 / 13600 / 12900 / 12700 with or without K for ECC.
13700 with ECC in the specs:
Intel® Core™ i7-13700 Processor (30M Cache, up to 5.20 GHz) Product Specifications
13400 no ECC in the specs...
Asus.
Supermicro reported correctly.
It is not a problem with Intel or Kingston.
Asus has not a single ECC recommendation on the QVL list but says on the Homepage they are supporting ECC.
This MoBos price tag is very high so I want them to deliver - and ECC is the only differentiating factor...
13700K and Kingston KSM48E40BD8KM-32HM in an Asus WS W680 I get 'totalwidth' 80bit
13700K and Kingston KSM48E40BD8KM-32HM in a Supermicro X13SAE I get 'totalwidth' 72bit
This is the screenshot from the X13SAE. In the other thread is a screenshot from the Asus board.
The Asus Board is...
Kingston UDIMM ECC KSM48E40BD8KM-32HM
inside a Supermicro X13SAE 72 bit wide
inside a Asus WS W680 80 bit wide
but in Windows when you call the wmic command in a powershell both Mobo says "5" single bit error correction.
I have a 13700K with X13SAE and Noctua NH-D15
Firmware BIOS 2.0a
With ECC you can run DDR5 4400
This Board is not meant for heavy OCing but it runs the CPU in a TDP area over 140W to 160W (my guess).
Cinebench R23 score is 10% lower than on a Z790 board but this is more because of the DDR5 ECC...
This are domain-joined workstations
But I am considering creating a new account on that device and "Microsoft-account-joining" this new account.
I have to test this first with a less "mission critical" workstation.
I had the chance to exchange CPU from PC1 with CPU from PC2.
PC1
Supermicro X13SAE with i7-13700Kstrong (this seems to be the one with the better/more robust integrated Memcontroller)
PC2
Asus WS W680 with i7-13700Kweak
When I install i7-13700Kweak into the Supermicro Board it is booting...
I have two KSM48E40BD8KM-32HM and the Asus WS W680 here.
and a Core i7 13700K
And it isn't running.
If I put only one DIMM into the Socket it is booting but with ridiculous fast RAM timings(normal for fast DDR5-RAM but too fast for DDR5-ECC).
One DIMM is even memtest stable.
But if you are...
Mainboard is Supermicro X13SAE-F
CPU is Intel i7-13700K
Mainboard firmware is 2.0
RAM is 2 x Kingston Server Premiere DDR5 ECC 32GB KSM48E40BD8KM-32HM
Memtest is version 10.2
Memoryerrorcorrection in Windows is 5
I hope this is helping a little bit
(Memtest 10.0 didn't recognize this...
This site uses cookies to help personalise content, tailor your experience and to keep you logged in if you register.
By continuing to use this site, you are consenting to our use of cookies.